Contractor disputes
The work is not done. Get precise.
A strong contractor dispute is a scope, payment, condition, and cost story. Photograph the work, check the contract, and ask for a specific cure or amount before deciding whether court is worth it.
Direct answer
You may be able to pursue a contractor for unfinished or defective work when you can prove the agreement, payment, promised scope, failure, and reasonable money loss. Document the condition and check required notice and repair opportunities before escalating. The right defendant, remedy, deadlines, and forum depend on your jurisdiction and contract.
Who to pursue
Start with the legal person or business named in your contract and invoices.
Confirm the business identity and license using the relevant official records.
Check any bond, insurance, or licensing-board route separately from your money claim.
A replacement contractor may be a witness or cost source, not automatically a defendant.
Evidence checklist
A practical escalation
Inspect
Record the condition and safety impact before changes.
Price
Separate completion cost, correction cost, damage, and amounts already paid. Avoid counting the same loss twice.
Demand
Send the scope, proof, requested cure or payment, and response date. Check required notice and opportunity-to-repair procedures first.
Check
Confirm notice, licensing, venue, deadline, claim limit, filing, and service rules using official local sources.
Enforcement is not recovery. California's CSLB explains that its investigations concern licensing violations and do not guarantee restitution. It asks whether the contractor was formally notified. This is a California example, not a nationwide notice rule. Check your own board and court.
Choose the next step
| Situation | Practical next step | Check before acting |
|---|---|---|
| Unsafe or actively worsening work | Make the site safe and document the condition before changes when practical. | Contact the relevant local building or safety authority; preserve inspection and emergency repair records. |
| Contractor offers to finish or fix it | Ask for a written scope, schedule, and who pays. Preserve the original evidence. | Check warranty terms, required repair opportunities, and any proposed release before agreeing. |
| No response or a disputed refund | Send a focused written demand with an itemized calculation and supporting records. | Check contract notice, statutory construction procedures, and filing deadlines. A requested date is not a universal legal deadline. |
| Licensing or conduct concern | Check the local licensing board's complaint process and the contractor's license. | A licensing complaint does not necessarily recover money. California's CSLB expressly does not guarantee restitution. |
| Clear money loss, still unresolved | Compare negotiation, mediation, and a qualifying court claim. | Verify the defendant, venue, claim limit, fees, service, and technical complexity. Seek advice for liens, major defects, or complex claims. |
Official sources
California resources apply to California. Elsewhere, use your state contractor board and local court for current procedures. This guide is general information, not legal advice.
Frequently asked questions
Can I sue a contractor for unfinished or defective work?
You may have a contract or consumer claim for a documented loss, but the remedy depends on the contract, payment history, licensing rules, notice requirements, and proof of defective work. A court decides liability and damages.
Should I let another contractor fix the work?
Get a written inspection and estimate first when safe and practical. Immediate work may be necessary to prevent further damage, but preserve photos, materials, invoices, and the original scope before demolition or replacement.
What should my demand letter include?
Describe the agreement, payments, unfinished or defective items, requested cure or money amount, supporting documents, and a response date consistent with applicable notice requirements. Do not claim facts or legal violations you cannot support.
When might small claims fit?
Small claims may fit a clear money dispute within the local limit when you can identify the contracting party, prove the agreement and loss, and satisfy applicable notice requirements. Construction disputes can become technically complex. Check your court's current rules.
Will a licensing-board complaint get my money back?
Not necessarily. For example, California's CSLB says its investigations concern contractor licensing violations and do not guarantee restitution. Financial recovery and licensing enforcement are different routes. Check the authority and process of the board in your own jurisdiction.
Does Petty guarantee a contractor will pay?
No. Petty drafts and sends demands for $29, with follow-ups and eligible phone outreach on the $49 plan. Eligible filing requires separate authorization, applicable fees, and court requirements. Payment, court acceptance, judgment, and collection are not guaranteed. Petty is not a law firm.
Make the scope impossible to miss.
Petty drafts and sends demands, follows up on eligible plans, and supports separately authorized eligible filing. Fees and court requirements apply. Petty is not a law firm and does not guarantee payment.
Related: demand drafting and sending guide · current pricing · business disputes